Far-right localism as an environmental strategy in France
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30671/nordia.140962Abstract
This paper discusses the promotion of localism as an environmental strategy by actors on the French far right. Far-right localism constitutes an example of mutating far-right ecological discourses on the denialism-ecofascism spectrum that further promotes far-right ideology under a ‘green’ banner. In this commentary I use empirical examples from the far right in France to show how this localism, which advocates a nativist rootedness in an exclusionary local, is upheld as a prerequisite for effective environmentalism. Such a strategy mobilises a reactionary conceptualisation of place that defends an exclusionary attachment to the local environment. Far-right localism feeds and revolves around an identitarian, naturalist and organicist conception of ecology typical of far-right ecologies, as well as the wish to supplant the left/right divide with a global/local one. This paper brings into conversation the fields of human geography and the political ecologies of the far right to contribute to a better understanding of constructed meanings of place by far-right actors in the context of climate change and ecological degradation. It furthermore encourages scholars across fields to keep investigating and disentangling complex affinities between ideologies of nature, identity (re-)production, belonging and resistance in conceptualisations and meanings of place.
References
Agnew JA (1987) Place and Politics. Routledge, London.
Amin A (2004) Regions unbound: Towards a new politics of place. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 86(1): 33–44.
Balibar E (1990) Is there a “Neo-racism”? In Balibar E & Wallerstein I (eds.) Race, Nation, Class – Ambiguous Identities, 17–28. Verso Books, London.
Benoist L (2021) Green is the new Brown: Ecology in the metapolitics of the French far right. Undisciplined Environments. 4 May 2021. https://undisciplinedenvironments.org/2021/05/04/green-is-the-new-brown-ecology-in-the-metapolitics-of-the-far-right/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Berg P (2001) Aux sources du biorégionalisme. Entretien avec Peter Berg, directeur de Planet Drum. Éléments 100 : 30–32.
Bernier A (2021) Localisme. In Burlaud A, Popelard A & Rzepski G (eds.) Le Nouveau Monde, Tableau de la France néolibérale, 721–731. Éditions Amsterdam, Paris.
Berteloot T (2020) Identitaires, RN: comment l'extrême droite veut tirer profit du coronavirus. Libération. 20 March 2020. https://www.liberation.fr/les-idees/2020/03/20/identitaires-rn-comment-l-extreme-droite-veut-profiter-du-coronavirus_1782297/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Biehl J & Staudenmaier P (1995) Ecofascism: Lessons from the German experience. AK Press, Edinburgh.
Bivar V (2022) The Patriot Ecology of the French Far Right. Environmental History 27(4): 618–624.
Bonesio L (2001) Paysages et sens du lieu. Éléments 100: 17–22.
Boukala S & Tountasaki E (2019) From Black to Green: Analysing Le Front National’s “patriotic ecology”. In Forchtner B (ed.) The Far Right and the Environment Politics, Discourse and Communication, 72–87. Routledge, London.
Campion K (2021) Defining Ecofascism: Historical Foundations and Contemporary Interpretations in the Extreme Right. Terrorism and Political Violence 35(4): 926–944.
Carle Z (2017) Contre-révolutions écologiques: Quand les droites dures investissent la défense de la nature. Revue du Crieur 8(3): 44–61.
Carle Z (2022) Men versus Wild: masculinités survivalistes. Itinéraires.
Cattin JD et al. (2013) Anti-mondial, Pro-local. Idées.
Cercle François Duprat (2023) Le Localisme.
Collectif Nouvelle Écologie (2016) Nos 21 propositions pour une écologie patriote au XXIe siècle. https://www.actu-environnement.com/media/pdf/news-28016-propositions-fn-ecologie.pdf (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Creswell T (1996) In Place/Out of Place: Geography, Ideology, and Transgression. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
Dannemann H (2023) Experiments of authoritarian sustainability: Völkisch settlers and far-right prefiguration of a climate behemoth. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy 19(1): 2175468
Damiron C (2022) Enracinement identitaire ou attachements terrestres ? Conflits autour de la réhabitation du monde. Terrestres. https://www.terrestres.org/2022/11/18/enracinement-identitaire-ou-attachements-terrestres-conflits-autour-de-la-rehabitation-du-monde/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
De Nadal L (2022) Climate Change: Bad News for Populism? How the Rassemblement National Used COVID-19 to Promote Its Environmental Agenda. Nationalities Papers: 1–16.
Davoudi S & Madanipour A (2015; eds.) Reconsidering localism. Routledge, London.
Devine‐Wright P (2013) Think global, act local? The relevance of place attachments and place identities in a climate changed world. Global Environmental Change 23(1): 61–69.
Devine-Wright P (2015) Local attachments and identities. Progress in Human Geography 39(4): 527–530.
Dubiau A (2022) Écofascismes. Grévis, Caen.
Ekberg K, Forchtner B, Hultman M, Jylhä KM (2022) Climate Obstruction. How denial, delay
and inaction are heating up the planet. Routledge, London.
Flint C (2004; ed.) Spaces of Hate: Geographies of Discrimination and Intolerance in the U.S.A. Taylor and Francis, Boca Raton, FL.
Flipo F (2022) Existe-t-il une écologie d’extrême-droite? Terrestres. https://www.terrestres.org/2022/12/23/existe-t-il-une-ecologie-dextreme-droite/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
François S (2016) L’extrême droite française et l’écologie. Retour sur une polémique. Revue Francaise d'Histoire des Idées Politiques 2(44): 187–208.
François S & Nonjon A (2021) “Identitarian Ecology” The Far Right’s Reinterpretation of Environmental Concerns. Illiberalism. https://www.illiberalism.org/identitarian-ecology-rights-reinterpretation-environmental-concerns/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Forchtner B & Kølvraa C (2015) The Nature of Nationalism: Populist Radical Right Parties on Countryside and Climate. Nature and Culture 10(2): 199–224.
Forchtner B (2019; ed.) The Far Right and the Environment. Routledge, London.
Forchtner B (2019a) Far-Right Articulations of the Natural Environment. In Forchtner B (ed.) The Far Right and the Environment, 1–17. Routledge, London.
Forchtner B (2019b) Nation, nature, purity: extreme-right biodiversity in Germany. Patterns of Prejudice 53(3): 285–301.
Forchtner B & Lubarda B (2022) Scepticisms and beyond? A comprehensive portrait of climate change communication by the far right in the European Parliament. Environmental Politics 32(1): 43–68.
Guillibert P (2020) La Racine et la Communauté. Mouvements 4(104): 84–95.
Harvey D (1993) From space to place and back again: Reflections on the condition of postmodernity. In Bird J, Curtis B, Putnam T & Tickner L (eds.) Mapping the futures. Local cultures, global change, 3–29. Routledge, London.
Herbert J & Powells G (2023) Contested geographies of localization(s): towards open locales. Globalizations 20(4): 548–563.
Hultgren J (2015) Border walls gone green: nature and anti-immigrant politics in America. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
Hogan A & Lockie S (2013) The coupling of rural communities with their economic base: agriculture, localism and the discourse of self-sufficiency. Policy Studies 34(4): 441–454.
Juvin H (2020) Pour une écologie enracinée : localisme et mise en valeur des terroirs (2/2). Insitut Iliade. https://institut-iliade.com/herve-juvin-ecologie-enracinee-localisme-et-mise-en-valeur-des-terroirs/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Koch N (2023) Geographies of nationalism. Human Geography 16(2): 200–211.
Langella J (2020) Pour une écologie enracinée : localisme et mise en valeur des terroirs (1/2). Insitut Iliade. https://institut-iliade.com/pour-une-ecologie-enracinee-localisme-et-mise-en-valeur-des-terroirs/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Les Localistes (2021) Manifeste. Les Localistes. Available at: https://www.leslocalistes.fr/manifeste-localiste/ (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Le Pen M (2021) Référendum sur l'écologie : le contre-projet du Rassemblement national, Rassemblement National. Youtube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4z-ZUOVjLU&t=1s&ab_channel=RassemblementNational (Accessed, 3 May 2023)
Lockwood M (2018) Right-wing populism and the climate change agenda: exploring the linkages. Environmental Politics 27(4): 712–732.
Lubarda B (2018) Polluting outsiders: green nationalism as a concept-case study: Latvia. Current Debates in Public Finance Public Administration & Environmental Studies 13(13): 436–446.
Lubarda B (2020) Beyond Ecofascism? Far-Right Ecologism (FRE) as a Framework for Future Inquiries. Environmental Values 29(6): 713–732.
Lubarda B (2021) Far-right Grassroots Environmental Activism in Poland and the Blurry Lines of ‘Acceptable’ Environmentalisms. In Krasznai Kovács E (ed.) Politics and the environment in Eastern Europe, 121–139. Open Book Publishers, Cambridge.
Lubarda B & Fortchtner B (2022) Far Right and Environment: Past-Present-Future. In Alfonso Bruno V (ed.) Populism and Far Right: Trends in Europe, 85–113. EDUCatt, Milano.
Macklin G (2022) The Extreme Right, Climate Change and Terrorism. Terrorism and Political Violence 34(5): 979–996.
Madelin P (2023) La Tentation Écofasciste : Écologie et extrême droite. Écosociété, Montréal.
Malm A and the Zetkin Collective (2021) White Skin, Black Fuels: On the Dangers of Fossil Fascism. Verso Books, London.
Massey D (1993) Power-geometry and a progressive sense of place. In Bird J, Curtis B, Putnam T & Tickner L (eds.) Mapping the futures. Local cultures, global change, 59–69. Routledge, London.
Massey D (2018[2000]) The geography of power. In Christophers B, Lave R, Peck J & Werner M (eds.) The Doreen Massey Reader, 191–196. Agenda Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne.
McCarthy J (2019) Authoritarianism, Populism, and the Environment: Comparative Experiences, Insights, and Perspectives. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 109(2): 301–313.
Miller-Idriss C (2020) Hate in the Homeland: The New Global Far Right. Oxford University Press, Princeton.
Moore S & Roberts A (2022) The Rise of Eco-fascism: Climate change and the Far right. Polity, Cambridge.
Nadaï A, Labussière O, Debourdeau A, Régnier Y, Cointe B & Dobigny L (2015) French policy localism: Surfing on “Positive Energie Territories” (Tepos). Energy Policy 78: 281–291.
Nagel C & Grove K (2021) Virtual forum introduction: Populist nationalisms and new geographies of exclusion. Political Geography 89: 102429.
Olsen J (1999) Nature and Nationalism: Right-wing Ecology and the Politics of Identity in Contemporary Germany. St. Martin’s Press, New York.
Paasi A (2003) Region and place: regional identity in question. Progress in Human Geography 27(4): 475–485.
Rassemblement National (2019) Pour une Europe des nations. Rassemblement National.
Sörlin S (1999) The articulation of territory: landscape and the constitution of regional and national identity. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift – Norwegian Journal of Geography 53(2–3): 103–112.
Tomaney J (2013) Parochialism – a defence. Progress in Human Geography 37(5): 658–672.
Turner J & Bailey D (2021) “Ecobordering”: casting immigration control as environmental protection. Environmental Politics 31(1) : 110–131.
Velegrakis G & Gaitanou E (2019) Open localization. In Kothari A, Salleh A, Escobar A, Demaria F & Acosta A (eds.) Pluriverse: A post-development dictionary, 259–262. Tulika Books, New Delhi.
Zarelli E (2001) Localisme et biorégionalisme. Éléments 100 : 25–30.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Lise Benoist
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
